If you even come near my social media right now, you can tell I’m at the Texas Tribune Festival. I’ve only been to a couple higher ed panels thus far, but so far so good. Here are some observations:
“Closing the Gaps”
So, I got here late, but this was a topic on last year’s tribfest and it seems nothing has changed. Basically the topic is how to help first-generation and high-risk college students get into school, afford school and graduate. This obviously delved into a little bit of high school education, but mainly stuck to challenges minority students face when it comes to a college education.
Only about 17% of community college students who say they want baccalaureate degrees get them. – @JulietVGarcia #TTFhighered
— Natalie Harms (@nataliejharms) September 20, 2014
“I never thought in my lifetime, I’d worry about men not going to school and women being the ones in college.” –@JulietVGarcia #TTFhighered — Cara Michelle Smith (@Cara_Smith5) September 20, 2014
We need to layout our plans and benchmark. We can’t hide our numbers. — Woody Hunt #TTFhighered #tribunefest
— Natalie Harms (@nataliejharms) September 20, 2014
In TX, a 60 hr. associates program takes 90 hours to complete, and a 120 hr. baccalaureate program takes 147 hrs. to complete. #TTFhighered — Cara Michelle Smith (@Cara_Smith5) September 20, 2014
“I happen to think it’s immoral if you admit students that you don’t think will graduate.” -Raymund Paredes, TX Higher ed Commissioner
— Cara Michelle Smith (@Cara_Smith5) September 20, 2014
Former HS math teacher from Loyola, TX said some of her graduating students struggled writing one-page essays with punctuation. #TTFhighered — Cara Michelle Smith (@Cara_Smith5) September 20, 2014
Panelists: UT-Brownsville President Juliet Garcia, TX Higher Ed Coordinating Board Chairman Woody Hunt, TX Higher Ed Commissioner Raymund Paredes, State Senator/Senate Higher Ed Committee Chairmen Kel Seliger, and A&M Chancellor John Sharp, with Tribune Reporter Reeve Hamilton.
“The Completion Crisis”
OK, Texas Tribune… name your panels better. Literally every panelist said that crisis was a misnomer. Maybe it was just a little severe, because they all did admit a problem. The panelists skirted around a few issues, but talked A LOT about outcomes-based funding for universities and community colleges. UH President/Chancellor Renu Khator expressed her support of outcomes-based funding and explained that UH already has a system in place with different colleges and universities in the system.
I 100% support outcomes-based funding, but it cant have redistributive properties & must be mission-based & depend on universities — @UHpres
— Natalie Harms (@nataliejharms) September 20, 2014
So did UT President Bill Powers.
We’ve got outcomes-based funding, and I can’t imagine not having it. Every bit of funding should have it — Bill Powers #TTFhighered
— Natalie Harms (@nataliejharms) September 20, 2014
But, they both agreed—along with the rest of the panel—that every school is different and there is not a one-size-fits-all approach to it. Universities will experience push back and will suffer some loss.
The outcomes-based funding metrics and measures are also not fully appropriate for all universities, since everyone is different and has different missions. Plus, where the funding goes should depend on what the school is succeeding at. Khator explained that these things need to be involved when holding students and administrators accountable.
Powers mentioned that the metrics are not beneficial, but didn’t provide his opinion on the best solution. 😦
The other problem is, with state outcomes-based funding, that while this issue has been introduced, state funding has declined. This presents a bigger problem. There’s not enough money it seems, to give to schools in general, let alone on an outcomes-based merit.
State appropriations have been declining while incentive-based funding has been developing & everyone is feels pinch—Natalicio #TTFhighered
— Natalie Harms (@nataliejharms) September 20, 2014
During the Q&A portion, the issue of student services arose. An audience member explained how she sees students struggling to find the right advisers and the right classes, and are therefore struggling to graduate on time. UH has addressed this recently, trying to introduce block scheduling and better advisers, but it was Powers who jumped at the question.
Powers: Providing a degree “roadmap” at large universities is the biggest challenge. We need to simplify the pathways. #TTFhighered
— Natalie Harms (@nataliejharms) September 20, 2014
Panelists: State Rep./House Higher Ed Committee Chairman Dan Branch, Khator, TX State Chancellor Brian McCall, UTEP President Diana Natalicio and Powers, with Hamilton as moderator.
In general, my first two panels have been great, but I am disappointed in the two panels for not talking about some of the bigger issues. Also, I think the responses to most of the questions were general and not saying anything ground breaking or innovative. What can ya expect.
ALSO, this happened…
LOL @reevehamilton identified Bill Powers as a representative of the most elite school in #TTFhighered panel & @UHpres said I’m not so sure
— Natalie Harms (@nataliejharms) September 20, 2014
😥 but go Khator/Coogs!
Here’s us:
Pingback: #TTFHigherEd — WitsForKicks | Digital and magazine journalist